Con to the question "Should the Government Allow Immigrants Who Are Here Illegally to Become US Citizens?"
"What heightens my concern is that we have history as a guide and history suggests this brand of so-called comprehensive immigration reform, this promise of enforcement as long as we have an amnesty, all of those things put together is a recipe for failure......the most notable case of this was in 1986 under President Regan. There was a so-called comprehensive immigration reform proposal that passed into law. And the promise, the model was very simple: 'We're going to get serious about enforcement, we really, really are. And we're going to have a one-time leniency or amnesty. And it will fix the problem once and for all, we'll never have to look back, and that will be done.'
Well, Mr. President, as we know from bitter experience since then, didn't quite turn out that way. The promised enforcement never fully materialized. In fact, in my fact in my opinion it never materialized in any, to any significant extent. However, the leniency, the amnesty happened immediately. It happened the second that bill was signed into law. And so did it fix the problem estimated at about 3 million illegal aliens then? No, it not only perpetuated the problem it grew the problem to 12+, some people think as high as 15-20 million illegal aliens now. So it grew the problem enormously because we had promised enforcement which never adequately materialized but an amnesty which happened immediately. That is the fundamental concern."
Remarks on the floor of the US Senate, gpo.gov, Jan. 28, 2013
Experts Individuals with advanced degrees in fields relevant to immigration. Also top-level government officials (such as foreign leaders, US presidents, Founding Fathers, Supreme Court Justices, members of legislative bodies, cabinet members, military leaders, etc.) with positions relevant to immigration.
Involvement and Affiliations:
US Senator (R-LA), 2005-2017
Former Chair, US Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship
US Representative (R-LA), 1999-2005
Member, Louisiana House of Representative, 1992-1999